It’s a standoff. 2 days before the start of her 11-year prison sentence, disgraced tech CEO Elizabeth Holmes locks eyes with comedian Nathan Fielder inside a rental house on the San Diego coast. “You’re being real right now?” he asks, and with a frozen smile and slightly cocked head, she replies, “I’m always being real.” In the teaser trailer for the mesmerizing and singular documentary You Can See Everything, which was kept under wraps until that minute-long clip debuted just 6 weeks ago, the intense close-ups of this interaction are resolved by a wider two shot revealing their faces are about a foot away from one another. We also get an answer as to why Holmes’ body seemed to be bobbing unnaturally in the previous frames: she’s been rocking her baby in a swing with an outstretched foot during this conversation. Things aren’t always what they seem.
Screened as a surprise addition to the Telluride Film Festival last month, You Can See Everything most closely resembles a magic trick in a world where magic is in depressingly short supply. It wouldn’t be Fielder’s first brush with wizardry. An episode of his satirical docu-reality series Nathan For You hinged on his ability to pick a handcuff lock in under 90 seconds to avert a fate “truly worse than death”. Last year’s season finale of his HBO show The Rehearsal revealed that he had been training for 2 years to obtain his commercial pilot’s license so he could fly a cabin of actors across the California-Nevada border. In addition to its short turnaround time from announcement to release, this almost 3-hour long documentary contains bombshells that may have already been spoiled for you following its impressive box office showing. I don’t plan on uncovering the film’s more surprising revelations here.
Lance Oppenheim, whose similarly buzzed-about first narrative feature Primetime was released just last month, co-directs with Fielder. The two, along with a limited camera crew, were invited in the spring of 2023 by Holmes and her partner Billy Evans to document their lives before the former CEO of Theranos heads to jail for defrauding investors. Though Oppenheim has directed several documentaries that were well-received in the critic’s community, he’s not the first name that might pop into your head when selecting someone to cover your exclusive pre-prison interview, and Nathan Fielder, even less so. Holmes and Evans say they saw a brief clip of him interacting with a convenience store clerk they thought was humorous and thought he’d do a good job. Are they lying? After he moves in with them, Fielder even points out the irony to them that his show Nathan For You was, in essence, about business scams. Holmes confesses she didn’t consider the correlation to her defunct tech company.
If the see saw of You Can See Everything is between authenticity and deception, then the fulcrum is the foundation of performance. Everyone inside of that beach house — probably even the scantily-seen camera crew — is performing for one another. It doesn’t mean they’re always being deceitful but it certainly doesn’t mean they’re being forthcoming all the time either. Though Holmes was found guilty by a group of her peers, she professes her innocence steadfastly and offers to show the crew the components behind the infamous blood-testing black box that led to Theranos’ demise. Elizabeth, perhaps subconsciously, performs her pitch to them, using hyper-specific language tailored to skirt fraud claims. She’s repeated the prospects of the technology that was proven not to work so many times, even she believes it. When Fielder points out the semantics in her proposal that misled investors, his use of a famous comedy routine to illustrate his point results in one of the year’s most captivating scenes.
Going into You Can See Everything, one could assume the convicted fraudster would be the main person “performing” for the camera but across the robust runtime, Oppenheim, and even Fielder, himself broach the idea that she may not the only one playing to camera. Billy has been with Elizabeth for 6 years at this point, enough to be a “true believer” in her deception, to the extent that he’s even mirrored the appearance of her hypnotic eyes. But does he really believe in Holmes or is he using her to further a new tech grift of his own? Fielder knows he’s literally face-to-face with an inscrutable figure, a dream subject for an exposé. Is he nodding politely to get Holmes to keep talking or is he actually buying into her lies? Just as waves lap the shore, the narrative current of this fascinating, first-rate doc perpetually makes and unmakes our perceptions of reality.
Score – 4.5/5
New movies coming to theaters this weekend:
Clayface, starring Tom Rhys Harries and Naomi Ackie, reimagines the DC Comics villain as a rising movie star who volunteers as a test subject to restore his original face after having been brutally disfigured but experiences a series of horrifying side effects.
Wildwood, starring Carey Mulligan and Mahershala Ali, is a stop-motion fantasy tale about a teenager who must find the courage to rescue her abducted infant brother from a hidden magical forest near their home in the Pacific Northwest.
Klara And The Sun, starring Jenna Ortega and Amy Adams, takes place in a dystopian future where technological advances in genetic engineering have divided humans into strict social classes, where an obsolete companion android tries to bond with a sick girl for whom she was purchased.