Johnny Depp selecting an A Christmas Carol adaptation as the project to spearhead his Hollywood comeback amid years of legal tumult is a seemingly sensible and safe choice. It’s easy to trace the outline of Scrooge’s cover-all redemption arc to whatever narrative Depp’s team is venturing to sell in regards to the actor’s fall from — and his attempt to return to — the A-list. Dickens’ indispensable novella is a story so familiar to audiences that Ebenezer shouldn’t, in theory, be a difficult pitch for folks to gather around for another telling of a holiday classic. The core narrative of the original tale is so sturdy that it’s a bit difficult to fumble its retelling completely but if the quality floor is high, the ceiling is also quite low too. There have been hundreds of iterations on movie screens and TV screens over the past century, so even if you’re radically reinventing the source material, it’s an uphill battle. This one doesn’t make it up the hill.
It’s Christmas Eve in Victorian London and the miserly money-lender Ebenezer Scrooge (Depp) is simply not in the mood. His like-minded business partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen) passed away seven years ago to the day, leaving the misanthropic Scrooge to toil alongside the comparatively cheerier clerk Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint). After begrudgingly granting Cratchit the following day off work, Scrooge trudges home and prepares for an undeserved sleep when he’s confronted by Marley’s ghost. Burdened by personified chains and shackles, he tells Scrooge to expect visits from the Ghost Of Christmas Past (Andrea Riseborough), Present (Tramell Tillman) and Yet To Come (Robert Strange) throughout the evening. In his time with the spirits, Scrooge comes to see the error in his ways and endeavors to change, lest he share Marley’s fate in the afterlife.
Our storyteller this time out is director Ti West, best known for his work in the horror realm with films like X and Pearl, and Ebenezer does indeed lean heavy into the haunts. Removing “Christmas” from the title and releasing the film closer to Halloween than December 25th both feel like intentional choices in hindsight. While there’s always been a ghastly element to A Christmas Carol, what with the presence of four apparitions meant to scare Scrooge into kindness, this rendering doesn’t balance out the portent and eeriness with comfort and cheeriness by story’s end. The oppressive dread in this version starts to feel one-note by the time we meet the Ghost Of Christmas Present, who’s just as menacing (if not more so) than Past as he withers away. “Come in and know me better, man!” is just about the last thing I would expect this Present to offer.
West and his scribe Nathaniel Halpern conspire changes to the Dickens’ classic here and there; Marley is famously “dead as a door-nail” at the beginning of the book but Ebenezer‘s prologue gives us a glimpse of Scrooge’s business partner the night of his death. It’s in this opening that West also establishes an odd undercurrent of mistrust towards the impoverished, presumably as an explanation for how Scrooge got so dang grouchy but not without its own distasteful messaging. Scrooge’s former boss Fezziwig shows up briefly in the Past stave, until his jolly dancing is interrupted by a flashforward of him getting fatally stabbed by a beggar. It’s a ponderous interjection that inadvertently defines the tone of Ebenezer: any time mirth or mercy threaten to creep into the story, West has to snuff it out with something horrible.
The actors doing their best to keep the candle lit as long as possible are Sam Claflin and Daisy Ridley as Scrooge’s determined nephew Fred and his wife Clara, respectively. They have the most screen time during the Present section, where Clara and company poke at Fred’s tireless efforts to reintroduce some warmth and compassion into Scrooge’s life. Most versions have Scrooge taking it on the chin, watching helplessly as others tear him down, and while there’s some cattiness in their conversation here, the scene gradually turns and a poignant note of empathy is struck. Ebenezer desperately needed more moments like this, scenes that signal what Scrooge could have again if he reforms, but West gets bogged down in the dreariness to such a degree that I hardly understand why he wanted to tackle this material. At least now we have a miserable PG-13 version of A Christmas Carol that’s too scary for kids. God help us, every one.
Score – 2/5
New movies coming this weekend:
Opening in theaters is The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping, a dystopian prequel starring Joseph Zada and Mckenna Grace, which takes place 24 years before the first Hunger Games movie, where the 50th edition of the Games necessitates each district send twice the number of tributes.
Also coming to theaters is I Play Rocky, a biopic starring Anthony Ippolito and AnnaSophia Robb, tells the true story of the stranger-than-fiction development and production of the underdog boxing tale and Best Picture winner Rocky.
Premiering on Netflix is Steps, an animated fantasy comedy starring Ali Wong and Amanda Seyfried, loosely adapts the fairy tale Cinderella where the titular princess aids her stepsister after she transforms her other stepsister into a frog.