In a time when the concepts of both “household names” and “event movies” are almost extinct, Steven Spielberg’s Disclosure Day represents something of a unicorn in popular culture. The olds may not be hip enough to know about Obsession or Backrooms but even the young folks (should, anyway) know about Spielberg and his career-long fascination with alien life. If the legendary filmmaker’s latest extraterrestrial spectacle belies the evaporation of monoculture and fracturing of our shared cultural touchstones, it’s fitting that the cache behind the film itself attempts to bridge the gaps. Attention being the most precious commodity a storyteller can yield, you’d better have something worthwhile to say when you have it. Alas, Spielberg and his scribe-in-arms David Koepp, who helped pen screenplays for Jurassic Park and 2005’s War Of The Worlds, simply do not this time around.
Disclosure Day opens on Dr. Daniel Kellner (Josh O’Connor), a brilliant mathematician and cybersecurity analyst under the employ of shadowy contractor WARDEX (Waived Reporting, Development and Extraction). He’s in possession of confidential footage depicting the existence of UFO crash sites over the decades, information that he maintains the world needs to see and is endeavoring to get in front of as many eyes as possible. Out to stop him in his whistleblowing mission is WARDEX CEO Noah Scanlon (Colin Firth), bolstered by a bevy of federal agents and their seemingly endless supply of black Dodge Chargers. During the search for Kellner, Scanlon is alerted to meteorologist Margaret Fairchild (Emily Blunt) unknowingly speaking an alien language during a live broadcast. Tying their stories together is Hugo Wakefield (Colman Domingo), a former WARDEX employee who now shares Kellner’s goal of disclosing the top-secret extraterrestrial intelligence to the public.
Within alien-enamored works earlier in Spielberg’s career like Close Encounters Of The Third Kind and E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial, there’s a sense of wonder and astonishment present that feels curiously absent in Disclosure Day. The possibility of life on other planets was integral to those classic tales but here, it’s treated as a plot point upon which to pivot these scurrying characters across state lines. It’s as if someone replaced the bold letters of that “I WANT TO BELIEVE” UFO poster with “I guess so…” Especially suspect for a Spielberg movie is clumsy storytelling, reliant on artifacts and gadgets whose capabilities are explained only in rudimentary fashion. This is the first time I’ve ever had the thought, “Did I miss a prerequisite TV series that set this up?” while watching one of his films, and he’s about the last director I would expect to generate those problems.
It’s one thing to have muddled mythology but the more troubling aspect of Disclosure Day is a reliance on tropes and types that Spielberg knows better than to recycle at this point. The characters and their motivations are often derivative of superior projects he’s completed within this genre and outside of it, whether it’s the man-on-the-run feel of Minority Report or truth-to-power conviction of The Post. On a foundational level, it was a poor decision to hinge the majority of the narrative on a manhunt when the company chasing after Kellner and his girlfriend Jane (played by Eve Hewson) has infinite tactical and technological resources. It’s presumably an excuse to have several car chases, including one that makes fair use of an oncoming train, but the action doesn’t comport with the heady sci-fi style that’s more in line with what fits the story.
Despite the futuristic set design and tech-focused dialogue, too much of Disclosure Day feels stuck in the past from a sentiment perspective. Perhaps in the 70s and 80s, a film about one man out to un-shutter the eyes of the American people from what the government is keeping from them could work. But we live in more cynical and jaded times, ones where it’s generally accepted that we’re being lied to constantly by people in power we’re supposed to trust. Spielberg making a film about whether or not finding out aliens existed would move the needle for humanity in the age of social media and AI is a more intriguing proposition. If that were the case, Discourse Day would be a more apt title. But the fact that the movie barely acknowledges the internet and, without spoiling too much, sets its climax within a TV production studio makes one wonder when Spielberg wrote the story Koepp used to adapt this script.
Score – 2/5
New movies coming to theaters this weekend:
Toy Story 5, starring Tom Hanks and Tim Allen, reunites Pixar’s secretly sentient set of playthings as they contend with their eight-year-old owner’s newest fixation: Lilypad, a smart tablet that threatens to jeopardize playtime forever.
The Death Of Robin Hood, starring Hugh Jackman and Jodie Comer, finds the titular heroic outlaw grappling with his past life of crime and murder while in the hands of a mysterious woman after being critically injured.
Leviticus, starring Joe Bird and Stacy Clausen, follows a teenager as he moves to a religious town and strikes up a forbidden, secret romance with a classmate, until the pair is subsequently stalked by a shapeshifting entity.
Reprinted by permission of Whatzup