Towards the end of 2024’s Kraven The Hunter, the sixth (and, God willing, final) chapter in Sony’s Spider-Man Universe, the titular supervillain’s half-brother is revealed to be Chameleon, capable of assuming the appearance and voice of whomever he chooses. It’s a strange choice for Clayface, the third film in the recently rebooted DC Universe, to not only reach across the comic book aisle and grab the anti-hero baton from that franchise but to specifically run with the shapeshifting thread it unintentionally left open. Sony at least had the excuse that they couldn’t use Spider-Man in that spin-off series, as they leased the rights to the webslinger to Marvel Studios, but Warner Bros has access to DC Comics’ full roster of characters right now. Why they followed up Superman and Supergirl with a full feature on a Batman villain, when Batman hasn’t appeared in the DCU yet, is beyond me.
At the opening of Clayface, things seem to be going great for actor Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries). He watches alongside his best friend Corey (Joshua James) and his manager Frank (Eddie Marsan) as Academy Award nominations are announced and, sure enough, he’s received a nod for Best Actor. To celebrate, Matt and Corey fly home to Gotham, cut the line at a packed nightclub and the Oscar nominee cuts a rug with Mia (Joana Ribeiro) on the dance floor. It turns out Mia has a boyfriend — crime lord Markos Szabo (David Dencik) — and as punishment for Matt cutting in with his girlfriend, Szabo cuts up the movie star’s face. Desperate to repair his carved-up moneymaker, Hagen looks to nanotech scientist Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie), who is working on a treatment that could heal his recently-mutilated skin, put him back on the A-list and get Matt his life back.
Clayface reportedly opens “Chapter One” of the DCU’s set of Gods And Monsters projects and without knowing much about what James Gunn and his team have planned, I would assume Clayface fits into the “Monsters” category. It would explain why the film, at times, resembles the story arc of a classic Universal Studios Monster; The Invisible Man would seem to be the closest analog. But director James Watkins zooms by the necessary character foundation for us to care about Matt Hagen first before his inevitable decline into the monstrous. The movie’s opening 15 minutes are ludicrously paced; the consequential events that lead to Matt’s downfall aren’t comical but the effort to cram them in before we can even take a breath is. Once Matt meets Dr. Corr, the film settles into a predictable rhythm of the two working to solve his condition, similar to Jared Leto and Adria Arjona from the SSU’s Morbius.
What keeps Clayface from reaching even Morbius-level quality kicks in around the halfway mark, when Matt decides the treatment is working well enough and he’s ready to carry out his revenge on those who betrayed him. But those pesky nanocells — there’s a line about how they’re controlled by AI that’s never explained or addressed again — they act up when Matt gets angry and cause his face to change into the person who’s drawn his ire. The actual “transformation” effect is goofy enough but the development leads to numerous scenes that trade the body horror tenor of the film’s first half for body swap hijinks in the back half. A third act sequence set in a club has Matt changing into about a dozen different strangers, even though it makes no strategic sense for him to do that. This is all after he corrals the crowd into a choreographed dance that all of these people randomly know somehow.
Speaking of music, the actual score, composed by Volker Bertelmann, is mainly stock superhero gravitas but does distinguish itself with an unsettling violin motif when Hagen explores his dark powers as Clayface. But the soundtrack choices are bizarre, mainly soul tracks from the likes of The Supremes, The Temptations and The Four Seasons that clash with the dread and portent of the story Watkins is telling. There’s also a Chicago song, used as a setup and callback, that’s so maudlin and unearned that I actually laughed during the reprise. Just as jarring was the funky strut of “Golden Years” by David Bowie playing over the film’s title card, which looks like it lifted its typeface from Shaft. Perhaps the attempt at camp or chest-puffery would’ve landed better in the Venom trilogy, whose biggest asset was Tom Hardy going gonzo in a dual role. In case it needs to be said, Tom Rhys Harries is no Tom Hardy.
Score – 1/5
New movies coming to theaters this weekend:
The Mosquito Bowl, starring Nicholas Galitzine and Bill Skarsgård, follows four top American football players who enlist in the United States Marine Corps after the attack on Pearl Harbor and play the titular match before being deployed in the Battle of Okinawa.
The Only Living Pickpocket In New York, starring John Turturro and Giancarlo Esposito, involves an aging career street thief, clueless about modern technology, as he steals and then loses possession of a device belonging to a young member of a major crime family.
Fjord, starring Sebastian Stan and Renate Reinsve, finds a conservative immigrant Romanian family living in Norway being subjected to scrutiny and an investigation after moving to the wife’s progressive remote Norwegian hometown.


