Released in the summer of 2022, The Black Phone wasn’t the most revolutionary horror movie in the world, but it provided a mix of gritty and supernatural scares while sporting several terrific child performances too. More pertinent to explain the existence of Black Phone 2, it made a whole lot of money at the box office. Even though the film was based on a short story whose narrative was completely told, writer/director Scott Derrickson and co-writer C. Robert Cargill have reunited to give the sinister child snatcher The Grabber an encore. Those who have seen the first movie may recall the pesky detail of that antagonist dying at the conclusion, complicating the possibility of a sequel. “Dead is just a word,” The Grabber taunts our hero over the phone in this chapter, although “braindead” is a more apt word I’d use to describe this pointless and trite follow-up.
It’s four years after the events of The Black Phone and Finney (Mason Thames) has gained a measure of unwelcome notoriety for slaying the serial killer known as The Grabber (Ethan Hawke). After having visions that helped the police find Finney during captivity, his sister Gwen (Madeleine McGraw) continues to be plagued by lucid dreams of children in peril. Her nightmares now center around a trio of kids trapped under ice at Alpine Lake Youth Camp, where Finney and Gwen’s mother served as counselor decades earlier. With her new crush Ernie (Miguel Mora), Gwen travels along with Finney to the Camp, where they meet the current supervisor Armando (Demián Bichir). It doesn’t take long after they arrive for a supposedly disconnected black phone to start ringing, opening the line for Finney and Gwen to converse across spiritual realms once again.
Where The Black Phone had a premise that tapped into the fantastical but otherwise remained grounded, Black Phone 2 chooses to lean hard into the mystical through lines of the original to justify its existence. If The Grabber was a psychopathic type along the lines of Norman Bates in that predecessor, he’s now gone full Freddy Krueger this time. The primary issue is that while the A Nightmare On Elm Street series has relatively straightforward narrative rules by which the characters are tethered, the limitations of The Grabber in the afterlife are woefully unclear. Like Freddy, his actions in characters’ dreams have violent consequences for them in real life but the scale of his powers fluctuates wildly depending on the scene. Likewise, the actual foundation of what Gwen and crew are meant to do at Alpine makes very little sense, whether you include The Grabber’s impact on the plot or not.
A positive aspect that Black Phone 2 carries over from its previous entry is uniformly strong performances from a younger cast, three of whom return here. Finney is clearly the main character in The Black Phone but he almost plays second fiddle to Gwen this time, whose paranormal abilities have more of a bearing on this storyline. Stepping into what is effectively the new lead role, Madeleine McGraw builds beautifully on her previous work with poignant and potent scenes that sell the emotion of her character. Sure, she doesn’t have as much to do when she’s screaming and running away from the bad guy but in the instances where she’s reconciling the untimely demise of Gwen and Finney’s mother and attempting to reconnect with her, McGraw shines. Mason Thames, who also led the live-action How To Train Your Dragon remake earlier this year, likewise does a great job transmuting his character’s sense of anger and cynicism after the traumatic events he endured years earlier.
Similarly to his still-best spookfest Sinister, director Scott Derrickson intersperses grainy scenes of menace shot on types of film germane to the 70s and 80s milieu of the Black Phone movies. The stylistic choice is still effective here but given that Derrickson’s used the same trick a few times before, I would’ve preferred to see more of a formal creativity in his storytelling. Beyond these interludes and the scathing snowbound setting, there just isn’t much that separates Black Phone 2 from generic hokum you’d expect from a 4th or 5th sequel in a horror franchise as opposed to the lone and likely last sequel in this series. If opportunity knocks and opportunism rings, I wish Derrickson had let the prospect of making this hollow follow-up go to voicemail.
Score – 2/5
New movies coming this weekend:
Playing in theaters is Springsteen: Deliver Me From Nowhere, a music biopic starring Jeremy Allen White and Jeremy Strong, which chronicles the conception and recording of the titular singer-songwriter’s stripped-back 1982 album Nebraska.
Also coming to theaters is Regretting You, a family drama starring Allison Williams and Mckenna Grace, which centers on the strained relationship between a young mother and her teenage daughter when a death in the family forces them to navigate life’s challenges together.
Premiering on Netflix is A House Of Dynamite, a political thriller starring Idris Elba and Rebecca Ferguson, following the U.S. government as it navigates an official response to a single nuclear missile launched by an unidentified enemy.
Reprinted by permission of Whatzup