The silver screen shield has officially been passed from Steve Rogers to Sam Wilson with Captain America: Brave New World, the first MCU movie with Anthony Mackie in the titular role. It’s been almost four years since the Disney+ miniseries The Falcon And The Winter Soldier, which set up the transition, and any inertia or excitement that show built up has largely been dissipated in the time since. It’s perhaps not a surprise, then, that this movie feels like it’s been pulled in a thousand different directions through its development and the result is about as inorganic an artistic endeavor as Marvel Studios has put in theaters thus far. Despite its subtitle, there’s very little “brave” or “new” about this film and whatever emerging “world” it’s ushering us into isn’t particularly enticing.
After stopping a sale of classified materials in Mexico, Captain America/Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) is invited to the White House by newly-elected President Thaddeus Ross (Harrison Ford, replacing the late William Hurt in the role). He tells Sam he’d like to form a new group of Avengers but that plan is put on hold when an attempt is made on Ross’ life later that same evening. Despite Ross’ insistence that he wants his team, led by security advisor Ruth Bat-Seraph (Shira Haas), to investigate the assassination attempt, Sam goes poking around with the help of the new Falcon (Danny Ramirez). Their efforts put them in the crosshairs of the special ops team Serpent Society, led by the ruthless Sidewinder (Giancarlo Esposito), but their mission uncovers an even deeper conspiracy.
It’s a shame that Brave New World is such a mess of plot holes and logic gaps because Anthony Mackie steps up to the challenge dutifully and gives his best performance so far as Sam Wilson. One of the film’s many themes and throughlines is about the pressure of taking over the mantle of an iconic hero and the imposter syndrome that Wilson feels in the process. There’s a muted subtext about the added pressure that is placed on Black artists when they enter the spotlight that applies to both Wilson the character and Mackie the actor. He more than holds his own in his scenes with Harrison Ford but is even better building rapport with Danny Ramirez and Carl Lumbly, the latter of whom plays a superpowered war vet who is mistreated by the government. I wish the movie had more time for them as a trio.
Instead, director Julius Onah and his four credited co-screenwriters are busy dredging up storylines from subpar MCU outings like Eternals and The Incredible Hulk in addition to the already convoluted political thriller plotline. Like Thor: Ragnarok before it, not only has the marketing for Brave New World spoiled the inclusion of a Hulk character in the film but the ads have leaned into a Captain America vs. Red Hulk showdown as much as possible. It’s deflating that we’re already seen much of the climactic battle, especially when we realize the film doesn’t have much else to offer in terms of story or spectacle. Given that, my favorite action sequence involves Captain America and Falcon intercepting two rogue pilots as they fire missiles at a Japanese fleet, which deftly captures the exhilaration of aerial combat.
If you look at a film like Captain America: The First Avenger, which also has the titular hero squaring against a red baddie, it took the time to develop who Steve Rogers was before and after taking the super soldier serum. Captain America: Brave New World doesn’t have the same obligation to an origin story but ultimately, Sam Wilson feels secondary to the plot machinations. In other words, this doesn’t feel like a project that had Captain America at its center during its development. It’s more concerned with resolving loose ends that no one cares about and setting up prospects for future episodes, including one subplot that hints at a revision of X-Men’s Wolverine. The Marvel Cinematic Universe has produced worse films than Captain America: Brave New World but I can’t think of one more fragmented or scatterbrained.
Score – 2/5
New movies coming this weekend:
Coming to theaters is The Monkey, a horror comedy starring Theo James and Tatiana Maslany, about a pair of twin brothers who witness a string of horrifying deaths unfolding around them, seemingly at the hands of their father’s vintage toy monkey.
Also playing in theaters is The Unbreakable Boy, a drama based on a true story starring Zachary Levi and Meghann Fahy, telling the tale of a young boy with both a rare brittle-bone disease and autism, whose life-affirming world view that transforms everyone around him.
Streaming on Apple TV+ is The Gorge, a sci-fi action movie starring Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy, involving two elite snipers who are assigned a mysterious mission: to guard either side of a deep and impenetrable chasm, without knowing what actually lies beneath them.
Reprinted by permission of Whatzup